This neighborhood favorite started out as a cafe and became a popular place to dine a few years ago. It still draws crowds for its few tables, despite the absence of drinks and bathrooms. Lillo's lasagna ragout is better than the one grandma made, their meatballs with an ideal texture and sauce are wonderful and their fettuccine with a touch of Parmesan cream sauce are almost too rich to stay in the memory. Aspiring restaurateurs in Park Slope should study this pleasant Fifth Avenue staple before their own opening ceremony.
Although it opened its doors in 1998, Al Di Là is still second to none in the neighborhood. Excellent Northern Italian dishes include ragù noodles, black spaghetti with octopus ragout and braised rabbit. Bamonte's is a New York classic that every red sauce lover should visit at least once. It opened its doors for the first time in 1900 and still retains a great old world appeal; the platonic ideal of a vintage Italian restaurant in Brooklyn with all the dishes on the menu at its height.
Now in its 28th edition, Il Buco is as in demand as ever, with an extremely rustic charm that hides a space that could also function as a film set. It reflects its flattering light on homemade pasta options, such as torchio with sausage at dusk, asparagus and pecorino, and noodles with black truffle and parmesan. Whether the notions of fashion attract you, like an influencer, to a photographic moment or sound forbidden alarms, it's remarkable that Dante is relevant 107 years after its premiere. The “best in the world” intermittent bar offers cheese dishes such as Spuntini and Salumi Misti, a variety of delicious pasta, and main courses such as branzino and chicken parmesana, in a place full of character.
Even with space for 70 people inside and two strips of sidewalk seating outside, Lilia is still packing after six years serving the best pasta program in the area. Its brick and wood interior is informally elegant, and the open kitchen offers hits such as spaghetti with anchovies and a wood-fired leg of lamb with Roman spices. Bleecker Street. Luquer Street.
Norfolk Street. Third Avenue. Vanderbilt Avenue. Second Avenue.
Gansevoort Street. I Sodi is also presented as one of the main candidates for the best restaurant in the city, even without the exception of leading the Italian cuisine category. New York Magazine rates I Sodi as excellent, just a couple of points below Gramercy Tavern or the revered dining destination Le Bernardin. Lasagna clearly stands out on the menu, but you can't go wrong with any of the homemade pasta, including pappardelle with lemon.
If you can't include a bottle in the wine list, consider one of the Negronis or amaros that don't skimp on quality. Code Switch, from NPR, reports that Astoria used to be known for its concentration of Greek and Italian-American residents and, although the cultural mix has changed, since people from about 100 countries live in the neighborhood, you'll still find one of the best Italian restaurants in New York. Goldfield writes with privileged information that an Esquire writer has sent chefs, politicians, friends and other food critics to the Italian restaurant to enjoy its unpretentious menu with lots of surprises; the all'ascolana olive, a selection of olives stuffed with minced pork, empanadas and fried foods, is the best recommendation. The Times also calls Tosti di Valminuta “the Empress of East Second Street” because it is one of the main Italian restaurants in the city.
If you want Italian-American cuisine, passing through southern Italy, the BBC reports that Arthur Avenue, in the Bronx, feels like the country's true Little Italy, thanks to its two dozen Italian stores and restaurants that have preserved the culinary tradition for more than a century. The art deco decor and private outdoor booths seem like conveyors, rather than repetitive, with the mauve details and coffee chairs that too many restaurants in New York City have decided are a requirement of modern cuisine. Depending on who you ask, Don Angie could be the contemporary version of an Italian-American restaurant that we've all been waiting for, or a self-conscious addition to a neighborhood brimming with quality options for handmade pasta that focuses on preparing food suitable for social media. Ci Siamo is part of the Union Square Hospitality Group, which also owns Marta, located at The Redbury New York hotel in Midtown.
This New York institution could hold the title of the oldest red sauce restaurants in the city, which is another way of saying that you'll find many classic pasta dishes with marinara sauce or vodka brought from southern Italy and popularized by places like this. But while the actor and founder of the lifestyle brand enjoys food, Goop says that other celebrities, Joan Didion and Jerry Seinfeld, New York institutions in their own right, have also dined at this place in uptown Italy. He arrived in the Belmont neighborhood with the intention of preparing inspirational dishes that would echo what Italian immigrants could have done when they arrived a century earlier, if they had the kind of fresh, quality ingredients available in today's New York City. This area is also home to Dommincks', an Italian-American place where New York Magazine published so many winks about its family-style offer that we are concerned about the permanent damage caused by eye strain.
According to the Travel Channel, Queens is one of the most ethnically diverse urban areas not only in New York City, but in the world, in addition to being part of the most densely populated counties in the country. The problem with compiling a list of the best Italian restaurants in New York is that there may be more here than in Italy. From rustic Tuscan dishes to tasty Sicilian specialties, this list of restaurants with seating service brings together the best of the best, both the new and the old, in New York City right now. The pizza restaurant that New York Magazine calls, in extreme Brooklyn, has a rooftop garden, bee hives and an on-site bread bakery, as well as a slightly ironic tiki bar.